Unfortunately, as something that attempts to pass itself off as a definitive first guide it falls short. Sadly, this is very little good historical information other than selected bits, and too many anecdotes about climbs (Bryan’s of course) that are 1-3 pitches. Grade V and VI climbs merit scant descriptions and no history while we read pages of ‘stories’ about short routes.

As well John Middendorff’s ‘history’, while interesting, misrepresents what happened before he arrived.

What Zion is badly in need of is a quality historical guide somewhat akin to Steve Roper’s original Yosemite guide, and a younger generation of climbers who has a lot more respect for the history of climbing than is currently the trend.

Oh well! Nevertheless, it is a pretty guide, and certainly worthy of purchase by weekend warriors.